NYC millennial Jonathan Baransky (Archie Colville) is something of an accidental cad. He’s openly seeing Lyla (Julie Bausivoir); secretly seeing his best buddy Frank’s wife Suzie (Mecca Alexis); and considering getting back together with his ex-girlfriend Jennifer (Kaelin Phillips). The part of him that recognizes that this is extremely complicated (and wrong) is suffering anxiety, so he seeks therapy from the eccentric Doctor Samantha Smithson (Olivia Fairless). Forward, flirty, and dressed like she’s about to perform Burlesque, Smithson proposes an unconventional treatment, utilizing “Dreamacil, the Magic Pill,” in the opening song. The wonder drug will induce a dream-like state where Jonathan will confront his issues to the accompaniment of showtunes and with the help of the wacky people that live in his head.

Dream On, Baransky! is the name of the show and its rallying cry, and this tremendously entertaining production written by Rich Baron is in its third imagining. The music and lyrics that accompany Jonathan’s surreal journey are by Dale Baron, with contributions from Alex Baker and Dan DeVere.

Jonathan’s psychedelic mind journeys are populated by a fun cast of quirky and wonderfully costumed characters that form the “army” dedicated to helping him find his way. Justin Knapp is the trenchcoated Commander Ted; Bea Corkhill is the level-headed Irish girl Reagan O’ Reilly; Andraes Ktorides is the uncouth, leather-jacketed Kazz-Nova; Hera Güneş Barlowe is perky cheerleader Patsy Purity; Alisa Mironoff is the shimmering Darlene Winters; and Jadé Porciatti is Daniela Divine and a host of other quirky surprise personas. They are distinct archetypes that are fun, familiar, and memorable, all well-realized by the sterling cast. Under their watch the befuddled, stressed-out Jonathan navigates both reality and the dreamscape in an escalating adventure that is quite surreal, but also familiar to anyone who finds life and dating in the big city rather overwhelming.

James Ahn Brandfonbrener (Musical Director) provides exceptional keyboard accompaniment to the playful and memorable songs, all beautifully rendered by the cast. A standout is “I Met This Man,” which sees Lyla, Suzie, and Jennifer come together to lament their Baransky-shaped dilemma. The production is imaginatively staged with many amusing things happening, from Frank suddenly rising from his hiding spot on the balcony clad only in a towel, to Dr. Smithson whimsically riding her office swivel chair to center stage during scene transitions. It all makes for an incredibly entertaining and funny show that also has some insightful things to say about mental health and the anxiety epidemic, and how they affect modern relationships.

Dream On, Baransky! is stylishly directed by Luana Seu, with Assistant Director/Stage Manager Paul Grant. It is featured at the John Cullen Theatre at the American Theatre of Actors through December 22, 2024.