John Galsworthy’s Compelling The First and The Last is Brought into the 21^st Century at the ATA

Cleaning up after a killing is never going to be an easy task (unless you’re Harvey Keitel’s character in Pulp Fiction). Such is the dilemma of Keith (Clay von Carlowitz), a young, successful, and ambitious lawyer with a wayward younger brother, Larry (Jonathan Beebe). Larry is madly in love with Wanda (Natasha Sahs), with a fervor that leads to tragedy. A distraught Larry visits Keith with the news that he has killed Wanda’s estranged ex after an altercation, and the couple had casually dumped the body under an archway. The murder is now all over the media, and Keith’s dilemma is how to make this “problem” disappear for his brother while protecting his own reputation. Keith’s investigation has him conclude that nothing directly implicates Larry, and the news of a vagrant discovering the body makes for a convenient distortion of the truth…

The provocative circumstances ensure that The First and The Last goes to 100 mph and stays there throughout its brief running time. Galsworthy’s play of over 100 years ago, itself based on a 1917 short story, is brought hurtling into 2025 by the actors, whose collective intensity is palpable. Amidst the powerful dialogue, the desperation of the situation is conveyed in their eyes, the glances between each other, the body language conveying human beings watching their very existences unravel. Beebe’s Larry is a deer in the headlights, his every expression and movement illustrating a man horrified by the dark corner of reality he has found himself in. Carlowitz’ dapper Keith is the picture of a man at a crossroads, trying to protect family while making sure his professional life is not tarnished, and grappling over which of those is most important to him. Sahs’ imbues Wanda with an astonishing potency that depicts a woman consumed by passion; Wanda starts in a black dress of mourning and traditions to a white wedding gown, hopelessly attempting to suggest an innocence that is no longer there. Ovid Radbauer provides a sinister, foreboding presence in the roles of a policeman and a paper seller, two people whose professions symbolize the very forces that could doom the brothers and Wanda.

Directed with a flourish by John DeBenedetto, The First and The Last is like a runaway train heading towards a brick wall of an ending that is shocking and yet somehow inevitable, and makes for a gripping hour of theatre. It runs at the Beckmann Theatre at the American Theatre of Actors through June 15, 2025.