MUD, María Irene Fornés’ 1980s social commentary, is reborn at the ATA

“I am a hungry soul. I am a longing soul. I am an empty soul,” laments Mae, an impoverished, illiterate young woman in an old torn dress. “Can’t I Have a Decent Life?”

Mae is living a bleak existence with an unwanted life partner, Lloyd—a man who is a virtual animal in human form. Their toxic relationship is marked by harrowing screaming matches as she goes about ironing and pressing clothes, desperately trying to maintain a civilized demeanor amidst the chaos. Mae finds what appears to be a way out in a possible relationship with the suit-and-tie clad Henry, a seemingly successful neighbor who to her is a symbol of education and escape. “I feel like heaven had come to this place and I still feel so,” Mae proclaims defiantly. But even that brief candle of hope is quickly extinguished due to an unexpected turn of events that leaves Mae in an even more dire situation than before.

MUD is a contemporary groundbreaker by María Irene Fornés’, the late Cuban-American playwright whose work was known for depicting characters who dared to dream themselves out of the dire and unfair circumstances that social and cultural realities imposed upon them. This important and relevant piece is now brought to life in 2025 by Utopia for Losers, “a New York-based theatre company of young actors and directors staging work by a variety of contemporary playwrights.”

Mae explains to Henry that her late father found Lloyd on the street and took him in; he is literally a feral stray that has resisted all attempts at domestication. He is dominated by base impulses of hunger and carnal desire, the latter hampered by an illness that leaves him physically impotent but still craving at a feverish level. “We’re like animals who got together and mated,” Mae admits with disgust. This leaves her forced to care for a person who is essentially an unwanted pet, a burden that hampers her desperate attempts to rise above the unfair cards that have been dealt her.

Chloe Margot gives a stunning performance as Mae, a heartbreaking heroine trapped in an utterly hellish situation; one roots for her to escape while recognizing how tragically unlikely that is. Mae is driven to better herself through education and a firm work ethic; she goes to school and has trouble retaining what she learns, but forges on regardless; she tries to develop her reading skills, narrating aloud (slowly but determinedly) books about starfishes and hermit crabs while trying to ignore the pathetic creature she is stuck in cohabitation with.

Brian Beckerle as Lloyd perfectly realizes the bestial, pitiful nature of the difficult character while never allowing him to tip over into being utterly repugnant. His physical acting is remarkable—Lloyd jumps onto the table repeatedly, exemplifying his subhuman nature, and cartwheels across the stage to demonstrate his virility and vigor. Aiden Castillo as Henry excels at an extremely difficult task of showing the character at first dominating but sinister, and supposedly civilized, until circumstances leave him compromised and forced to a state of dependency similar to Lloyd’s. The trio of actors give a masterclass in the realization of a playwright’s intent, expertly interpreting Fornes’ poetic style and bringing to life her themes of psychological and relationship complexity fueled by poverty. It’s a triumph for the cast, Director/Producer Dylan Pitanza, Assistant Director Christopher Paul Richards, Dramaturg Ava Lamantia, and Producer Sawyer Barth; and a home run production for Utopia for Losers and the American Theatre of Actors.

Content Warnings: Profanity, discussion of sexual acts, simulation of a sexual act, gun violence, discussion of bestiality, misogyny. 

MUD was performed by the American Theatre of Actors through June 29, 2025.