Director James Jennings has gifted American Theatre of Actors aficionados with another successful Shakespeare production at the John Cullum Theatre with this season’s Richard II. The text is word-for-word intact and as the Bard intended, and the play is cast with familiar faces from previous forays into his work, who have the passion and experience to deliver it well.

This production is a Tale of Two Sams: Sam Cruz is perfectly cast as the titular king, and co-producer Sam Hardy is commanding as ever as Bolingbroke, as he fights to seize the crown and become Henry IV. Cruz brings an energy and lightness to the king that is crucial to the portrayal and to the narrative, and makes his downfall all the more tragic. His Richard is arguably the most likable character, so his abdication, imprisonment, and final fate are genuinely heartbreaking; even his successor is saddened—or claims to be. Hardy plays Bolingbroke with a noble elegance tinged with a hint of menace and a layer of steel, perfectly contrasting Cruz’s almost benign Richard. Annie Unger is excellent as the queen, creating a powerful moral presence as she tries to be a beacon in the ever-growing darkness until it can no longer be contained. Her gorgeous gown changes symbolically from white to dark in between acts. (And speaking of costuming, Bolingbroke’s outfit after he takes the crown is suitably fabulous). Shakespearean stalwarts Jane Culley and Emery Lawrence shine in the pivotal roles of the Dutchess of York and John of Gaunt.

Richard II—a rarely performed part of the canon— is a story of political intrigue, so the physical action is minimal; but when it does occur, it’s impeccably choreographed and well served by the dramatic buildup. At 3 hours it requires patience and concentration from the audience, but the Return on Investment is undeniable. Kudos to producers Hardy and Jennings and the cast and crew for delving into the Shakespeare catalog and bringing us a terrific deep cut.

Richard II is performed at the American Theatre of Actors through August 16, 2026.